From classic to wild, these top 10 Pop-Tart flavors prove that breakfast just got a whole lot more delicious.
Curious about the best Pop-Tart flavors? I’ve rounded up my top 10 flavors, from timeless classics to bold, unexpected combinations, so you can satisfy your sweet tooth with the ultimate breakfast food.
Pop-Tarts have been a beloved breakfast treat for decades, offering a perfect balance of convenience and sweetness. With a variety of flavors to choose from, it’s no surprise that some have become fan favorites over the years. Whether you’re a fan of fruity or indulgent, there’s a Pop-Tart flavor for everyone. In this list, I’ve rounded up the top 10 flavors that stand out for their taste, texture, and timeless appeal.
From the classic Strawberry and Brown Sugar Cinnamon to more adventurous options like S’mores and Pumpkin Pie, Pop-Tarts have continually pushed the boundaries of flavor innovation. With their deliciously frosted exteriors and gooey centers, each bite delivers a burst of nostalgia, while newer flavors bring a fresh twist. These 10 selections represent the best of both worlds, celebrating the tried-and-true while introducing bold new taste experiences.
No matter how you enjoy your Pop-Tarts—straight from the package, toasted, or with a side of ice cream—these top 10 flavors will elevate your snack game. Whether you’re starting your day or indulging in a midday treat, these flavors have earned their place as the ultimate Pop-Tart experience. Ready to find your new favorite?
The top 10 list
- Frosted Strawberry Milkshake
- Frosted S’mores
- Frosted Cherry
- Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon
- Frosted Strawberry
- Frosted Cookies and Creme
- Frosted Hot Fudge Sundae
- Frosted Blueberry
- Frosted Wildberry
- Frosted Chocolate Fudge
Time to dive into my top 10 list. The number is Strawberry Milkshake. There is a reason this flavor is number 1. First, it is a very underrated flavor. Many people have not had this flavor and once they do it will change their life forever. The Frosted Milkshake is a creamy, fruity filling with a smooth, sweet frosting that tastes just like a refreshing milkshake in pastry form. Number 2 is S’mores. The reason I put it number 2 is because it’s a fan favorite and not only that it is very good. The S’more pop-tart combines a graham cracker crust, gooey marshmallow filling, and rich chocolate frosting for the perfect bite of campfire-inspired sweetness. And this makes it a great flavor for anyone looking for a breakfast item. Number 3 is Cherry. This is a flavor that is just mouth watering when eating it. The cherry pop-tart features a tangy, sweet cherry filling encased in a flaky crust, topped with a sugary glaze for a burst of classic flavor which places this at third. Number 4 is Brown Sugar Cinnamon one of the reasons this is 4 is it is an original flavor being one of the frost to come out in 1967. This is a flavor I always hear people craving when they say they want pop-tarts. The brown sugar cinnamon pop-tart delivers a warm, comforting blend of sweet cinnamon and rich brown sugar, perfectly paired with a crisp, golden crust.
The next three flavors will have you in a dream because of how good they are and that matchup of these next 3 are great. Number 5 is Strawberry with this also being one of the first flavors to come out in 1967 this is an oldie but a goody. The strawberry flavor offers a sweet, fruity filling with a burst of fresh strawberry flavor, all wrapped in a flaky, golden crust and topped with a sugary glaze. This simply makes it at pick number 5 and an overall great buy for anyone. Number 6 is Cookies and cream. This got 6 on my list because not only do I like cookie and cream ice cream but the pop-tart flavor that William Post ( creator of pop-tarts) created is simply just amazing. The cookie and creme flavor combines a rich, chocolatey filling with crunchy cookie bits, all encased in a smooth, sweet frosting for a decadent treat. Number 7 is hot fudge sundae. There are two reasons this is number 7 on my list. First, from it being a pop-tart flavor I could never find and getting my hands on these anytime was like me on Christmas opening presents. Second is that the flavor is so good it features a creamy chocolate filling, topped with a rich, sweet frosting and a drizzle of fudge, capturing the indulgent flavors of a classic sundae.
These last three pop-tart flavors might have some people in shock or maybe agree with it. But with that being said let’s begin on the last three flavors. Number 8 is blueberry with this also being an original flavor. Is it something I used to have all the time from being a little kid. The cool color of the white frosting and sprinkles is amazing. The blueberry pop-tart is a sweet, tangy blueberry filling encased in a flaky crust, topped with a sugary glaze for a deliciously fruity treat. Number 9 is wildberry. This flavor is starting to become more popular as time goes on. From the delicious flavor of it to being a wonderful bright color. The Wildberry Pop-Tart combines a vibrant blend of mixed berry flavors in a sweet, gooey filling, all wrapped in a flaky crust and topped with a colorful, sugary glaze. Lastly, with the last pop-tart on this list being chocolate fudge this flavor deserves to be top 10 because who doesn’t like chocolate fudge and then it goes farther into being made a pop-tart flavor. The Chocolate Fudge Pop-Tart features a rich, velvety chocolate filling encased in a soft, flaky crust, topped with a smooth, sweet chocolate frosting for an indulgent treat. With that being the last pop-tart flavor on the list this loss is truly the best list you will ever see. Now go and try some of these flavors and see which one makes your top 10 list.
